Responsive Search Ads vs Expanded Text Ads (ETAs)
Expanded Text Ads were sunset by Google in June 2022 — you can no longer create or edit them. Responsive Search Ads (RSAs) are now the only standard Search Ad format, using AI to combine your headlines and descriptions into the best-performing combinations.
Responsive Search Ads (RSAs)
Current standard Google Ads text format with up to 15 headlines and 4 descriptions — Google automatically tests combinations to find the best-performing mix.
Pros
- Automatically optimized combinations
- More headline and description variety = more relevance
- Adapts to different search queries
- Google's AI selects best performing combinations
- Up to 15 headlines provide extensive A/B testing built-in
Cons
- Less control than ETAs over exact messaging shown
- Pinning headlines/descriptions limits optimization
- Combination report requires analysis to find top performers
- Quality depends on asset variety provided
Best For
All Google Ads Search campaigns — RSAs are the mandatory standard format as of June 2022. Every campaign must use them.
Expanded Text Ads (ETAs — Legacy)
Previous Google Ads format with 3 fixed headlines and 2 fixed descriptions per ad. Deprecated since June 2022 — can no longer be created or edited.
Pros
- Complete control over exact ad messaging shown
- Predictable performance
- Simple A/B testing (variant A vs variant B)
- Historical data available for analysis
Cons
- Cannot create or edit since June 2022
- Static format misses query-specific optimization
- Less relevant than RSAs across varied search queries
- Being phased out — pause or delete underperformers
Best For
Historical reference only — review your existing ETA performance data to inform RSA headline and description writing.
The Verdict
ETAs are legacy — focus entirely on RSAs. Best RSA practice: provide all 15 headlines and 4 descriptions with genuinely different angles (keyword-focused, benefit-focused, CTA-focused, social proof), pin one brand headline to position 1, check the Combinations report monthly to see top-performing asset pairs, and create 2–3 RSA variants per ad group for testing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Do not delete performing ETAs — they still serve and can provide useful benchmark data. Google shows whichever ad (RSA or ETA) it predicts will perform best. Pause ETA ads that have poor performance metrics, keep those with good performance until your RSAs clearly outperform them, then pause all ETAs to simplify account management.
Related Service
Google Ads Management
Related Comparisons
Facebook Ads vs Google Ads: Full Comparison 2025
Google Ads vs Microsoft Ads (Bing): Which is Better?
Manual Bidding vs Smart Bidding in Google Ads
Instagram Ads vs Facebook Ads: Which Performs Better?
Not Sure Which Tool to Choose?
Our experts can audit your current marketing stack and recommend the right tools for your goals and budget — free consultation.
No credit card required. Response within 2 business hours.
Let Us Choose the Right Platform For You
Instead of comparing tools yourself, let our specialists recommend and implement the exact stack that fits your business goals, budget, and team size.
Get a Free Platform Recommendation
Tell us your goals and we'll advise on the best tools for you.